While my heart bleeds for the affected people of Kerala Floods, it is surprising that proper questions are not asked of the Current and Past Governments. It is as if there is a conspiracy to ensure this doesn't happen. A point to note being the deliberate controversy created over the non existent Rs 700 crore aid offer by the UAE Government, which was used to abuse the Central Government and Modi, who went out of their way to offer all the assistance to Kerala.
I would like to post some key points here.
Now that the flood waters have receded, many are pointing fingers at the Government, who in their wisdom chose to wait till the last moment to open 34 Dams at one go. It is clear that the priority of the Government was to store as much water as possible to generate Electricity at a later date, and save money for the exchequer. One can't fault them. It was an error of judgement, with hindsight. Till the last minute, even experts were commenting on TV that Idukki dam may not have to be opened. We can give the benefit of doubt to the Government here. But the question to be asked is different.
"In this era of Computer simulations, did the Kerala Government have multiple simulations as to various scenarios with respect to opening of shutters of various dams and to what happens when shutters are opened partially or fully?"
It is clear they did not have this, as the flash floods caught them unawares. The sad fact is that all it required was some foresight and a few lakh rupees to create this simulations, rather than depend on assumptions.
Kerala Economy has been dependent on remittances from Overseas for a long time. And due to vested interests, the Government has been lax in collecting tax, especially from Jewellers and many leading businessmen, leading to the State being in perpetual financial crisis for a long time. The Chief Minister's initial assessment of the loss due to floods was Rs 20,000 crores, though the final figure could be much higher. Despite being a non BIMARU state, and considered to be prosperous for a long time,
"Why is it that the Kerala Government do not have Rs 20,000 Crore as a Contingency Fund?"
It is almost pathetic to see the Government virtually begging for money from all and sundry. And being ungrateful when someone offers aid to them.
This brings me to the next point.
I am a Malayalee myself. It pains me to see the attitude of my fellow Malayalees. The so called 'literate' and 'progressive' State has been 'demanding' that every one helps them, and considers it their god given right to be helped. I saw people demanding that Film Stars donate in Crores, and anyone who offered in lakhs were criticized!. By abusing the Central Government and rest of India, which offered all the help, including Interim relief, and offer to reconstruct the state (the NTPC, REC etc have already had a discussion with KSEB to replace all the damaged sub stations and transformers, and Nitin Gadkari has promised to reconstruct all the destroyed roads, just to give examples) Malayalees have shown once again that they cannot overcome their petty prejudices, and even a calamity of this magnitude has not taught them to be humble and behave with humility
"When will Malayalees learn to be humble, not feel a sense of entitlement, and respect others?"
And,
"Will this disaster make us develop plans for being self-reliant in future'?
(Update 03-09-2018 - At last, in Newspapers and TV Channels, people are talking about 'Flood Mapping', which is what I meant when I said 'Computer Simulation'. Though I don't think anything will be done on this front, at least there is awareness now)
(Update 03-09-2018 - At last, in Newspapers and TV Channels, people are talking about 'Flood Mapping', which is what I meant when I said 'Computer Simulation'. Though I don't think anything will be done on this front, at least there is awareness now)
